Man Sees Nitto Grappler Tires Are $450 On Amazon. Then He Goes To Walmart: ‘Just Taking A Chance And Hoping For The Best’

Some opportunities are so gargantuan, there’s no sense in only going in halfway. That was the case for a retail-arbitrage reseller who recently spotted what looked like a massive pricing error on premium Nitto Grappler tires online, with the potential of cashing in a mid-five-figure return if he acted fast.

In a TikTok clip, creator @marketplaceflipsandtips shares the details of his gambit on buying 50 sets of the premium off-road tires for less than $100 per tire, or less than 25% of their typical retail price. By borrowing every spare dollar he could, he hoped to capitalize on the pricing glitch for a rare, major score.

“This is the price that I can flip these for $1,000 a set tomorrow and, like, sell them all. And I can pick them up for $400 a set,” he said in the clip that’s been viewed more than 35,000 times.

The opportunity first surfaced through a tip from a friend.

“I get a text from a buddy, and he's like, 'Hey man, these Nitto Grappler tires right now are $93 on Walmart.com,'" the creator explained.

Walmart: Top-Tier Tires, Bargain Basement Price

The listing immediately stood out since Nitto Grapplers are a popular high-end truck tire commonly found on lifted pickups and off-road builds. He said comparable listings sn Amazon showed prices at $450 per tire. Even while acknowledging something seemed unusual about the pricing, he decided the potential reward justified the risk.

“If it was, it'd get refunded,” he said. “So I'm like, I'm gonna take the chance,” he said, adding that it felt like the time to take a big swing since Facebook Marketplace sellers confirmed they’d resell the tires for up to $1,600 per set of four.

“I max out every credit card, debit card, have two or three people I know do the same thing. Ordered 50, 60 sets of these tires.”

If the orders went through, he believed there was a chance to grab a substantial profit. That optimism didn't survive the night, however.

“So I wake up today, and of course I see the emails: ... 'Sorry, you've been refunded.' 'Order canceled,'" he said. He added that one supplier attributed the issue to what appeared to be a product-listing mistake involving a nearly identical tire code. However, he had hope that he might still score premium tires from the other supplier he purchased from, especially because some orders had already shipped out.

Viewers Weigh In

The video's comments section quickly filled with viewers comparing notes on similar pricing glitches and debating whether the creator's gamble would ultimately pay off.

Some remained optimistic that at least a portion of the orders might survive. Others were considerably more skeptical, arguing that retailers and suppliers almost always catch obvious pricing mistakes before products make it to customers.

Unfortunately for @marketplaceflipsandtips, the would-be bargain didn't result in a warehouse full of discounted off-road tires that he planned to move in a hurry. 

"Dang, yeah I didn't get any!" he replied, without offering exact details on how the orders vaporized. "And then they tried to deliver just three singular tires basic 15 inch car tires. I just drove up to Walmart and had them refund me."

Another commenter claimed the outcome sounded familiar.

"I saw this last year and people were getting lawn mower tires because it was a mix up online with the tire codes," the viewer wrote.

Not everyone was convinced the strategy made sense in the first place.

"Your counting your chickens," one viewer wrote.

The creator didn't deny that the entire plan hinged on a long shot succeeding.

"No, just taking a chance and hoping for the best!" he responded.

Priced To Move Fast

The short-lived pricing error was so enticing because Nitto Grapplers occupy a premium corner of the truck-tire market and are highly sought after by owners of customized Ford Super Duty, Ram Heavy Duty, and Chevrolet Silverado pickups. Depending on the specific model and size, a set can easily cost $1,500 to $2,000 before installation, particularly in the larger sizes favored by owners of lifted pickups and heavily modified off-road builds.

That widely known popularity is why the creator immediately began calling Marketplace sellers to gauge resale demand. He was wise to do some preliminary research before taking such a big gamble, since more obscure and modest automotive parts can sit for months waiting for a buyer. Premium truck tires occupy a large and active market, with drivers always on the lookout for a deal on four-figure tire purchases.

If the purchases had gone through, the difference between the listed price and the prevailing retail price tag could have translated into tens of thousands of dollars in profit. Instead, it turned into a prolonged game of “what if?” that’ll almost certainly keep the creator on the lookout for more big potential paydays.

Motor1 reached out to the creator via direct message and comment on the clip. We’ll update this if they respond.