Man Puts A Deposit On A Truck. Then The Dealership Puts It Back Up For Sale: 'A Dealership Is Not A Bank'

A salesman at a Missouri family-owned dealership says a customer put a $500 non-refundable deposit on a 2016 Ford F-150, agreed to return with a check, and then went radio silent for a full week, ignoring calls, texts, and emails.

The dealership is planning to put the truck back on the market and keep the deposit, but the video has split commenters between two camps: customers calling it shady and other car dealers calling it standard practice.

5StarSalesGuy (@newsalesguy), a sales rep at 5 Star Motor in Blue Springs, Missouri, posted the video on April 27. It has since drawn more than 85,000 views.

2016 Ford F-150: ‘He Was Going To Buy It’

"We took a deposit on this ‘16 F-150 going on a week ago, last Monday," 5StarSalesGuy begins. "Five hundred-dollar non-refundable. Buyer and seller have agreed that that car is sold. Today is Monday, the following week. I have called him; no answer. I have texted him; no answer. … I have emailed him; no answer."

He says the deposit was documented in writing and was, in his words, "enforceable in the state of Missouri."

He says they had to take an unprecedented decision. "For the first time in company history, we have put a car up for sale after having a non-refundable deposit on it," he says. "Unbelievable. This kid really liked this truck. He was kid younger than me and said he was going to buy it. Left the deposit on it, bring us a check, and I can’t get a hold of him."

In a reply to a commenter speculating the customer might be in the hospital or dealing with a family emergency, 5StarSalesGuy clarified that the buyer had actually texted him, "saying he’s been looking at other trucks."

Can Car Dealerships Keep Your Deposit?

Can car dealerships keep your deposit? It depends on the state, the contract, and how the dealer wrote things up.

According to FindLaw, there is no universal federal rule on car dealership deposits. Whether a dealer can keep a non-refundable deposit depends on state consumer protection law and whether the buyer signed a written agreement clearly stating that the deposit is non-refundable.

Missouri, where 5 Star Motor operates, is generally a dealer-friendly state on this issue. As long as the deposit is documented in writing with the buyer’s signature and the non-refundable language is clear, the dealer is typically within their rights to keep it.

---

---

Other states are markedly stricter. Pennsylvania consumer-protection rules prohibit dealers from keeping a deposit unless the contract contains a specific dollar amount, is "clear and conspicuous," and is initialed separately by the buyer. New York generally entitles consumers to a refund if they decide not to proceed with a purchase. Connecticut requires dealers to disclose in writing whether a deposit is refundable or non-refundable at the moment it’s taken.

There are also common scenarios in which even non-refundable deposits must be returned. If the dealer can’t deliver the vehicle as agreed, financing falls through despite the buyer’s good-faith efforts, or the dealer changes the terms of the deal, they must return the deposit. Consumer law firms also note that some "liquidated damages" clauses get struck down in court when judges decide the retained amount is wildly out of proportion to the actual harm to the dealer.

The Comments Split Down The Middle

The video’s comments section showed how fragile dealer reputation can be.

Customer-facing complaints came fast. "Legitimate dealers don’t take deposits," wrote Alton. "Another dealership to avoid," added VeryInteresting. Heyitsterra wrote, "I will NOT buy any vehicle that requires a deposit. Looks like a cheap buy here pay here lot."

But the loudest defenses came from other dealers, sales reps, and finance staff in the comments section, many of whom said exactly the opposite.

"A dealership is not a bank. They’re not there to hold your money," wrote Petermont3. "Lots of customers think they can just leave a deposit so we won’t sell it while they look at other vehicles."

GMCCLINT pointed out the opportunity cost for the dealer. "And had to hold it another week and floor it another week and advertise it another week which costs money," they wrote.

A few commenters predicted the customer would simply file a credit-card chargeback and win. "He will just do a charge back and bank will side on his side," wrote 11bravo/whiskey1. Crosscut | Diesel Trucks pushed back, claiming to have personally won "20+ deposit chargebacks."

What The Buyer Could Have Done

Russell Alberson II flagged an interesting wrinkle. "Unless your ‘in writing’ contract has a date or time limit, when you sell that vehicle, you just voided the contract and that deposit becomes refundable for breach of contract," he wrote.

Awhitener, a North Carolina dealer, described a different structure that sidesteps the dispute entirely: "I take what is called a non-refundable ‘holding fee’ on vehicles and will never take a ‘deposit’. The holding fee … will hold the vehicle for up to a week, and if the customer follows through with the purchase then we refund the $500 or deduct it off the price."

For buyers, the practical advice from consumer law sources is to read the deposit paperwork before signing, ask whether the deposit is refundable in writing, and be wary of any deposit on a vehicle you aren’t ready to buy within the next few days.

Motor1 reached out to 5StarSalesGuy via a direct message on TikTok for additional comment. We’ll be sure to update this if he responds.

 

 

We want your opinion!

What would you like to see on Motor1.com?

Take our 3 minute survey.

- The Motor1.com Team