Home

BMW

3 Series

News

Wide Versus Narrow Winter Tires: It Doesn't Really Matter Which You Choose

The general consensus is you should go narrower for your winter tires, but real-world testing shows it doesn't really matter.

wider versus narrower winter tires video

10:09

Brian Silvestro Brian Silvestro

By: Brian Silvestro

Nov 19, 2023 at 12:00pm ET

Add Motor1.com as a preferred source in Google

Share

Comment

There's an age-old theory that proposes one should go for narrower tires in the winter because a narrower tire puts more pressure on a smaller contact patch, thus generating more grip. The contrasting argument is that you should use a wider tire, as more surface area on the road will generate more grip. But as Jonathan Benson at Tyre Reviews discovered, it doesn't really matter whether you go wider or narrower for your winter setup.

Benson wanted to test the theory of wider versus narrower winter tires himself, so he sourced four sets of Hankook tires to run on a BMW 3 Series around a snow-covered closed course, each wider than the next. The tires ranged from 205 section-width up to 275s, with the 205s installed on 16-inch wheels, the 225s resting on 18s, and the 255s and 275s mounted on 19-inch rims.

What do you think?

View

Comments

While there were subjective differences in feel and feedback between the sizes, the numbers don't lie. The narrowest tire performed the best in acceleration testing, but did the worst when it came to braking. And for lap times, the middle 225 section-width tire performed the best. But all of the results are so close that you probably wouldn't notice the difference.

More Winter Tire Tests

SUV Winter Tire Test Shows Why AWD Doesn't Help With Turns And Stops

See 11 Winter Tires Show How They Handle Chilly Weather And Snow

The main conclusion, Tyre Reviews says, is that you'd find more of a variance in objective performance between a good winter tire and a bad winter tire using the same tire size. So if you're shopping for winter rubber, your best bet is to focus on brands with good reviews rather than stress about what size you should choose. 

Source: Tire Reviews / YouTube

We want your opinion!

What would you like to see on Motor1.com?

Take our 3 minute survey.

- The Motor1.com Team

Share this Story

GO TO COMMENTS

(

)

Got a tip for us? Email: tips@motor1.com

View all comments ( )

Popular

Driven: The New Audi A2 Is Proof Small Cars Still Make Sense

Driven: The New Audi A2 Is Proof Small Cars Still Make Sense

Aston Martin Is Taking Its Call Of Duty Off-Roader To Dakar

Aston Martin Is Taking Its Call Of Duty Off-Roader To Dakar

Ford Will Sell The Dark Horse SC's V8 And DCT, Minus The Mustang

Ford Will Sell The Dark Horse SC's V8 And DCT, Minus The Mustang

Ford Maverick Buyers Can Get The 300-HP SV300T Package Before Taking Delivery

Ford Maverick Buyers Can Get The 300-HP SV300T Package Before Taking Delivery

Inspiring The Next Generation Of Mechanics

Inspiring The Next Generation Of Mechanics

Latest Stories

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU



BMW’s Next Electric Wagon Spied Ahead Of 2027 Reveal: Video



Mercedes Is Auctioning A Rare C 111 Supercar With A Rotary Engine



BMW's Electric 3 Series Makes Gas Hard To Justify: Driven



Ford Will Sell The Dark Horse SC's V8 And DCT, Minus The Mustang



The New BMW M350 Feels More Like An M3 Than Ever: Driven



Cupholders In Cars Weren't Always A Thing



BMW's First Electric 3 Series Wagon Spied Looking Nearly Ready For Production