Home

News

Texas Woman Trades '26 Honda Odyssey for '17 Toyota Sienna. So Was It a Fair Trade?

"I guess I'm a part of the Toyota cult now."

Texas Woman Trades ‘26 Honda Odyssey for ‘17 Toyota Sienna.

Photo by: tarr_nation & Rinat Aidarkhan

JT Wilson

By: JT Wilson

Oct 24, 2025 at 2:00pm ET

Add Motor1.com as a preferred source in Google

Comment

A Texas woman's decision to trade her brand-new 2026 Honda Odyssey for an older Toyota Sienna has sparked debate among minivan enthusiasts. Kim Tarr (@tarr_nation) detailed her reasoning in a TikTok video that has garnered over 92,000 views since being uploaded last week.

Tarr posted the 3-minute, 20-second video explaining why she made what many might consider an unusual trade. "I traded my 26 Honda Odyssey Touring for a 2017 Toyota Sienna Limited. Let's get into why I did that," she begins in the video, speaking directly to the camera while sitting in her car.

The TikTok, captioned "I guess I'm a part of the Toyota cult now," has resonated with viewers who shared their own experiences with both minivan models.

Quality Control Issues Drive the Decision

Tarr was quick to clarify that her decision wasn't financially motivated, though she acknowledges the pecuniary benefits of the trade. "So before we get into that, let me say it was not for financial reasons," she explains in the video.

Instead, Tarr cited multiple quality control issues with her brand-new Odyssey as the primary reason for the switch. "Honda needs to get it under control with their quality control. I bought this brand new vehicle—seals like around the door were already popping off. I already had to take it in for an upholstery issue where it started to develop a hole," she says.

The problems extended beyond just interior issues. "My doors on my passenger side weren't even lined up correctly. No lines were meeting up," Tarr notes, expressing frustration with the build quality of her new Honda.

What Drivers Are Saying

The Toyota Sienna Still Rocks

The Updated Honda Odyssey Borrows One Thing From the NSX

There is public information that supports her hunch. Recent safety and reliability data show Honda has faced broader quality concerns in select models, including an ongoing National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) investigation into 1.4 million Honda and Acura vehicles (some Odyssey units among them) over potential V-6 engine failures. The 2024 Odyssey also saw recalls related to steering gear assemblies and mirror brackets.

That said, the Odyssey continues to earn strong overall reviews from major outlets. Car and Driver put the vehicle at number five in its list of best minivans, just three spots behind this year's Sienna. Tarr’s reported issues may be isolated bad luck rather than evidence of a systemic manufacturing flaw.

Performance Preferences in Small-Town Texas

Beyond quality concerns, Tarr explains that the Odyssey's performance didn't suit her driving environment. Living in a smaller Texas town where "everyone is very aggressive when they drive," she says she needed a vehicle with better pickup for highway merging.

"I need to be able to get on the road and get up to speed. If you know what I'm saying, because if you don't have a car that has a little pickup around here, you might get squished," she explains in the TikTok.

Tarr also criticized the Odyssey's air conditioning system, calling it "weak" and suggesting that potential buyers "get an older one that has vents on the top" if they plan to transport children regularly.

Gallery: 2025 Honda Odyssey

2025 Honda Odyssey

Source: Honda

Why the 2017 Sienna Made Sense

Despite being nearly a decade older, according to Tarr, her 2017 Toyota Sienna Limited came with more features than her brand-new Odyssey. "For the price that they are charging for those cars, there should be more things. My 2017 Sienna has more features than that Odyssey did. That is a ‘26, just saying," she remarks.

Understanding the comparison requires some nuance. The 2017 Sienna Limited was one of the highest trims of that model year, featuring leather seating, dual moonroofs, and a powerful V6. Toyota’s 3.5-liter V6 produced 296 hp and 263 lb-ft of torque and was praised for “lively acceleration” by Edmunds.

Meanwhile, recent Odysseys—depending on trim—include advanced driver-assist tech, 12-way power front seats, and Honda’s Magic Slide second row, as shown in the manufacturer’s official feature comparison. So while Tarr’s Limited trim Sienna may genuinely have offered more premium amenities than her particular Odyssey, that’s not necessarily true across trims or generations.

The V-6 engine in the older Sienna also provided the performance characteristics she was seeking. As she explains, "The Sienna V-6 has faster acceleration than the Sienna hybrid," addressing viewer questions about her choice to avoid the newer hybrid models.

Gallery: Toyota Extreme Sienna - SEMA 2016

Toyota Extreme Sienna - SEMA 2016

Community Reactions Split on the Trade

The video has generated strong reactions from viewers, with opinions divided on whether Tarr made the right choice.

Several commenters shared similar experiences with Honda quality issues. "My coworker's Odyssey had MAJOR MAJOR engine issues! I just don't think Honda is what it used to be and people don't want to admit that," wrote user Shelly.

Another commenter, who claimed to be a Toyota salesperson, offered perspective on the performance differences: "The Sienna hybrid actually do get up to speed faster. I sell Toyotas, but I don’t blame you for wanting the V-6. I prefer the V-6 to less to go wrong in the long run lol," wrote Logan Henson.

However, not all viewers agreed with Tarr's assessment. "The Odyssey has way way more pickup than the Sienna," countered user streéet.

Some questioned her comparison methodology. "Trim level matters. You went from a [2026] base model to a 2017 nearly fully loaded. It's gonna have more features in it," pointed out mrmahstudio.

Real-world testing data back up the general performance gap Tarr described. According to Planet Honda, the current Sienna hybrid delivers 245 hp and reaches 60 mph in about 7.5 seconds, while the Odyssey’s 280 hp V-6 does the sprint in around 6.5 seconds. Car and Driver also notes the Sienna’s hybrid setup favors efficiency over acceleration, describing it as providing “an uninspiring driving experience” compared to the Odyssey.

In short, Tarr’s preference for the V-6 aligns with the data: the older gas-powered Sienna offers stronger acceleration, though both vehicles serve different priorities—power versus efficiency.

The Broader Honda vs. Toyota Debate

Tarr's experience has reignited the ongoing debate between Honda and Toyota loyalists in the minivan segment. Several commenters shared their own brand-switching stories, including Jason E, who wrote, "I just traded my 2024 Jeep Grand Cherokee for a 2018 Toyota Avalon lol."

RachelWhitePhaup expressed satisfaction with Toyota's minivan offerings: "I loved my Toyota siennas! I had 2!! I now have a Highlander."

For Honda defenders, some acknowledged quality concerns while maintaining brand loyalty. "I absolutely will be loyal to Honda forever but I do agree with you… their window seals and power windows in general I've noticed are just sloppy at best," wrote one user.

Long-Term Strategy

Tarr views her trade as part of a longer-term strategy. She plans to pay off the Sienna quickly and drive it until her children outgrow car seats, at which point she'll consider purchasing a new Toyota.

"I knew once I paid it off I was going to want to trade it in. So I decided to take the hit and keep this car a long time, pay it off in a year, and save for a new Toyota when my kids are out of car seats and I don't need a van anymore," she explained in response to a commenter.

What do you think?

View

Comments

As for her final verdict on the trade? "I'm never leaving Toyota ever again. Uh-uh," she declares at the end of her video.

Motor1 has reached out to Tarr via TikTok comment and direct message for additional information. We'll be sure to update this if she responds.