What are the pros and cons of Farmers Insurance coverage?

Advertiser Disclosure

Farmers auto insurance is one of the nation’s oldest choices for insurance and ranks among the best. We’ve scoured the car insurance market to bring you a comprehensive list of the providers of the best auto insurance and match you with the right coverage plan for you. Farmers auto insurance made our list for excellent coverage, and Farmers insurance reviews from drivers across the country agree with us. Read on to find out what factors distinguish Farmers from other auto insurance companies. 

Use our quote comparison tool below to get started. Or, for an even easier process, call our team at (855) 518-0148 to get free, personalized quotes seven days a week.


In this article:

Farmers Auto Insurance Overview

Farmers auto insurance provides coverage options for drivers in every stage of life. Given the strong customer reviews and ratings and the company’s high Better Business Bureau rating, it seems the Farmers auto insurance program has a lot to offer. 

We’ve taken into consideration Farmers Insurance financial standing, customer service, availability, cost and discounts, coverage options, and technology to paint you a better picture of Farmers. Here’s a quick snapshot:

  • Fast, free online quotes always available
  • 24-hour customer service with personalized service and local agents
  • Discounts for homeowners, safe driving, defensive driving courses, and more
  • Add-on options include new car replacement accident forgiveness



Good selection of coverage add-ons

Customer complaints about high premiums

Many discount opportunities for customers with safe driving records

Complaints about roadside assistance availability and rental car options

“A” (Excellent) AM Best Rating

Average customer service 

High-rated apps 


Farmers Auto Insurance Coverage Options

Get peace of mind knowing you’re covered on the road. Traditional coverage from Farmers covers bodily injury liability, property damage liability, collision coverage, comprehensive coverage, medical payments, personal injury protection, and coverage against uninsured/underinsured motorists.

Supplemental coverage options are also available for:

  • New car replacement
  • Accident forgiveness insurance
  • Custom equipment protection
  • Original Equipment Manufacturer
  • Loss of use coverage
  • Guaranteed Value™
  • Towing and roadside service
  • Rideshare
  • Personal umbrella
  • Glass and windshield coverage

Looking To Cover A New Car?

Farmers Insurance offers the New Car Pledge®, which guarantees a replacement for newly purchased vehicles that are a total loss. The totaled vehicle will be replaced with a new car of the same make and model at full market value without depreciation as long as the car has less than 24,000 miles on it and is less than 2 model years old. If your new car can be repaired, Farmers will cover original equipment manufacturer parts when available. 

Farmers Auto Insurance Costs

Premiums vary by state and the type of coverage you decide to purchase. With that being said, the average rates for car insurance from Farmers is $1,538 according to U.S. News & World Report. Some of the other factors that could affect the cost of your premium include your location, driving record (speeding tickets or making a claim cause your premium to go up) and the type of coverage you purchase. 

Discounts With Farmers Auto Insurance

The discount opportunities offered by Farmers give you the power to improve your eligibility by making changes to your driving style or your car’s features. Discounts with Farmers depend on what state you in live, but some examples include:

  • Good driver discount
  • Homeowner discount
  • Discounts for adult drivers and students/teens with parents who have safe driving records
  • Good student discount
  • Occupational discounts (applicable to doctors, nurses, RNs, firefighters, police officers, etc.)
  • Senior defensive driving discount for people age 55 or older after completing an online safety course provided by AARP
  • Alternatively fueled vehicle discount (ie. electric cars)
  • Airbags, anti-theft technology, and other safety features
  • Discount for having policies for multiple vehicles with

Here are some additional things you could do to improve your chances of qualifying for discounts: 

  • Bundle auto insurance with home insurance or life insurance to save by becoming a multiple policy holder
  • Pay your policy in full 
  • Pay electronically 
  • Take a defensive driving course 
  • Use Signal®

Signal is Farmers’ app that monitors your driving behavior, and can qualify you for even more discounts. It tracks how fast you drive, brake, accelerate, and other driving habits. Once you sign up for Signal and complete 10 trips, you’ll receive a 5-percent policy discount. When it comes time to renew your policy, you could be eligible for up to a 15-percent discount, based on the driving score the app gives you. 

Filing A Claim With Farmers Auto Insurance

Farmers’ online services and app allow you to report claims and manage policies on-the-go. Google Play rates the Farmers app 4.6 stars for usability based on customer reviews.

The Farmers Claim Services team is available 24/7 to answer questions or concerns regarding your claim. In the U.S Property Claims Satisfaction Survey, J.D. Power gives Farmers claim servicing three out of five stars. The length of time it takes to handle a claim depends on the claim’s complexity, the severity of damages and/or injuries, and the compliance of the other parties involved.

Getting A Quote From Farmers Auto Insurance

To get a quote for Farmers car insurance, you’ll need:

  • Your driver’s license
  • Vehicle information (including any information regarding extra equipment or security features)
  • Information about your commute and how many miles you drive daily
  • Information on the other drivers in your household

They’ll ask you to answer a few more questions to be sure you’re getting the correct coverage and possible discounts. You can either all the company or go online to get a free, no-obligation quote in minutes. 

We recommend using this easy tool, or calling our team at (855) 518-0148to compare the best options in your area.


Farmers Auto Insurance Reviews

There are many positive aspects to using Farmers Insurance as your auto insurance provider. The company has a consistent A+ BBB rating, which takes into account the company’s age, complaints, and transparency of its business practices.

Farmers car insurance has been praised in customer reviews in many areas, including:

  • A wide array of coverage options
  • High-quality claims support
  • Many discounts available

Although there are many reported benefits to using Farmers Insurance Group to provide auto insurance, the company is not without its shortcomings in the eyes of consumers, as seen in some customer concerns:

  • Recently, customers have raised the issue of reliability when it comes to Farmers customer service. Farmers Insurance is a niche company with a smaller network, so they have less resources at their disposal, especially when it comes to roadside assistance. People have reported waiting one to two hours for a Farmers agent to find an available tow in the customer’s area. 
  • Customers have also reported issues with their rental cars and replacement vehicles being a lower caliber car than the one being repaired. 

Farmers Insurance Review: 4.0 Stars

Industry Standing

4.5 / 5

Farmers ranks seventh for direct premiums written and market share percentage, according to the NAIC. Plus, AM Best gives Farmers an “A” for the company’s Financial Strength Rating (FSR).

Customer Service

3.5 / 5

J.D. Power rated Farmers claim servicing 3/5. Consumer Reports rated Farmers Insurance customer service 72/100. 


5 / 5 

Farmers Insurance is available in all 50 states.


3 / 5

Farmers Insurance offers multiple discounts for safe driving, bundling for multiple policy owners, and students and senior citizens.


4 / 5

Farmers Insurance has standard coverage plus a good selection of add-ons.


5 / 5

Customers can get a fast, free online quote. There is also a mobile app, so customers can manage insurance policies from anywhere. The app has a 4.6 star rating averaged from more than 4,000 Google Play reviews. 

Overall Ranking

4 / 5


We’re giving Farmers Insurance four stars out of five compared to the company’s competitors like USAA auto insurance, Progressive car insurance, Geico car insurance, and State Farm car insurance, and others. 
While Farmers auto insurance offers good plans and coverage, it’s smart to get quotes from more than one insurance company when shopping for auto insurance, which is why we’ve compiled a list of the best auto insurance providers.

Other Auto Insurance Providers To Keep In Mind

When you’re looking for car insurance, it’s important to shop around and compare auto insurance quotes. We recommend considering Progressive or State Farm as other contenders to protect your vehicle.

Progressive: 4.5 Stars

Our review of Progressive auto insurance found that this company is a good option for drivers in their 20s and people with a DUI in their driving history. Progressive is one of the top insurance providers in the U.S. The company has positive online reviews from satisfied customers and awards from reputable sources like J.D. Power and Fortune 500. 

Auto insurance from Progressive includes bodily injury and property damage coverage, collision coverage, comprehensive coverage, protection from underinsured or uninsured motorists, medical coverage and personal injury protection, plus add-ons for things like:

  • Roadside assistance
  • Rental car reimbursement
  • Custom parts and equipment value
  • Rideshare coverage

Progressive has many money-saving features including a deductible savings bank, bundling, a usage-based program called Snapshot, and Name Your Price® Tool that quickly lets you see a plan that fits your budget. 

Costs for Progressive Auto Insurance can vary depending on your state. To get an online quote from Progressive, you need your driver’s license information, vehicle information, ticket history, and current coverage (if you have it). Online, you’ll have the opportunity to compare car insurance quotes from other insurance providers side-by-side. As with all insurance providers, there is an underwriting period that lasts between 30 and 120 days, depending on what state you live in.

State Farm: 4.5 Stars

We’ve also reviewed State Farm auto insurance, which is a popular auto insurance provider that ranks 36 on the Fortune 500 list and has over 83 million policies and accounts. Standard coverage with State Farm includes bodily injury and property damage, collision coverage, comprehensive coverage, medical payments, personal injury protection, and protection against underinsured or uninsured motorists. 

They also offer extra coverage for rental and travel expenses, ridesharing, and roadside assistance. State Farm offers competitive discounts for safe driving, safe vehicles, and loyalty discounts. The company’s Drive Safe & Save™ discount includes lower prices for low annual mileage and safe driving habits, tracking data such as:

  • Acceleration speed
  • Braking
  • Cornering
  • Driving speed
  • Phone use
  • Time of day 
  • Time traveled

To get a quote from State Farm, you’ll need your driver’s license and car information. Complete a form online or can call the company to speak to an agent.

Use this tool to compare fast, free online quotes from reputable auto insurance providers servicing your area, or call us at (855) 518-0148. 


Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Does Farmest auto insurance policies cover car rental?

A: Yes, Farmers auto insurance policies cover most types of car rentals, such as passenger cars, pickup trucks and SUVs. While driving your rental car, you will receive the same amount and types of coverage that are covered by your personal policy.

Q: Is Farmers a good insurance?

A: Based on our research, we recommend Farmers insurance as one of our top insurance companies for auto insurance. Learn more about our review standards in our review of the top auto insurance providers.

Q: Does Farmers Insurance check your credit?

A: Farmers Insurance uses a code develeped from and based on your credit report information as one of your Farmers Risk Assessment Indicator when you are applying for a policy. Farmers' underwriters may also use your motor vehicle records, loss reports and/or other information to determine the rates of your auto and/or homeowner insurance policies.


Read our other insurance articles: