See if a car insurance policy from Shelter Insurance can give you the best coverage.

Advertiser Disclosure

Shopping for car insurance can be overwhelming. There are hundreds of car insurance companies in the market today, competing for your business with a dazzling array of coverage options, discounts, and benefits. How do you know if you are making the right decision? 

We tried to make your job a little easier by researching over 30 of the best car insurance companies and ranking them based on different factors such as financial strength, customer service, affordability, and coverage. Today, we will evaluate Shelter Mutual Insurance against these providers and help you decide if this company can give you the best car insurance coverage.

See if Shelter Mutual Insurance is available in your state and get a free quote by calling Motor1's designated quotes team at (855) 518-0148 or filling out this form:


In This Article: 

Shelter Mutual Insurance Overview

Shelter Insurance has been in business for over 70 years and is headquartered in Columbia, Missouri. While the privately held company initially offered auto insurance only for residents of Missouri, it’s now a leading insurance provider for home, auto, life, farm, and business in 15 states: 


Colorado Illinois Indiana Iowa


Kentucky Louisiana Mississippi Missouri


Nevada Ohio Oklahoma Tennessee

In 2018, Shelter Insurance wrote private passenger auto premiums worth more than $980,000,000.



Shelter Mutual Insurance Coverage Options

Shelter Mutual Insurance provides several coverage options for car insurance buyers. Your basic Shelter Insurance auto policy will include bodily injury liability, property damage liability, roadside assistance, and new car replacement coverage. You can also buy policy add-ons, such as collision coverage, comprehensive coverage, medical payments coverage, rental reimbursement, and accidental death. 

Liability: Bodily Injury And Property Damage

Bodily injury liability and property damage liability coverage are the two main types of car insurance coverages and are mandatory in most states. If you have bodily injury coverage and cause an accident where someone gets hurt, it will help pay for the medical expenses of the other party. This coverage could also help with your legal expenses, such as bail bond or defense fees, if you are arrested.

While most states have a minimum amount of required bodily injury coverage, it is generally a good idea to pay a little more to get better coverage because medical expenses can jump sky high in serious accidents. If the bills exceed your policy limits, you could be on the hook to pay the difference. 

If you caused an accident that damaged another person’s property, your property damage liability coverage will help pay for the cost of repairs or replacement. Similar to bodily injury liability, most states will require you to have a minimum amount of property damage liability coverage.

Roadside Assistance

All Shelter Insurance auto policies include 24/7 roadside assistance provided by Road America. This benefit pays up to $100 per accident for services such as battery jump start and towing. 

New Car Replacement

If you total your new car in an accident, Shelter Insurance’s new car replacement coverage will help you replace it with a brand new car of the same make, model, and year, as long as the original purchase was within the last year and the car had less than 15,000 miles on it.

Shelter Insurance Optional Coverages

In our Shelter Insurance review, we found that in addition to the above coverages, which are included with every Shelter Insurance auto policy, the provider also offers other optional coverages, including the following:

Collision Coverage

Collision coverage will pay for repairs or replacements to your car if you were in an accident, regardless of who was at fault. There will be a deductible amount before you are able to claim the benefits. While collision coverage is optional in all states, if you are leasing your car or financing it, your lender may require you to have this coverage.

Comprehensive Coverage

While collision coverage will pay for your car’s repairs if you were in an accident, it will not cover your expenses if the damage was caused by an uncovered cause such as fire, weather, flood, or theft. In such cases, you will need comprehensive coverage. 

As with collision coverage, comprehensive car insurance will have a deductible amount. Since some causes of loss are excluded from the coverage, we always recommend that you discuss the terms and conditions with your provider up front. Also, while comprehensive coverage is optional in all states, your lender may require it if you are leasing or financing your car.

Medical Payments

Medical payments coverage will help for ambulance costs, hospital bills, and other medical expenses for you and your passengers in a covered accident. It also covers funeral expenses. 

Personal Injury Protection 

In the case of a covered accident, personal injury protection or no-fault coverage can help you cope with routine medical expenses, loss of income, and the cost of services like cooking or housekeeping that you would normally provide for your family and are unable to do because of your injuries. Personal injury protection is required for all vehicle owners in some states.

Uninsured Motorist (Bodily Injury And Property Damage)

This is insurance for if you are injured in an accident caused by someone else and that person is uninsured or doesn’t have enough insurance to cover the full damages amount. Your uninsured motorist bodily injury coverage may help pay for your medical expenses and car repairs.

Accidental Death Coverage 

Accidental death coverage provides benefits if you or your spouse dies in an auto accident. You can purchase coverage for other members of your family, too.

Gap Coverage

If your car was totaled in an accident and your collision coverage will not cover the amount you still owe on your auto loan, the gap insurance coverage will help pay the difference. 

Rental Reimbursement 

If your car was stolen or needs repairs after an accident, rental reimbursement coverage will help pay for the cost of renting alternate transportation.

Disability Income Coverage

If you are unable to return to work for a long time because of your injuries from a car accident, disability income coverage will pay you a weekly stipend for up to one year. Please note that this coverage option may not be available in all states.

Loss of Use

Loss of use coverage will give you a one-time payment if your car is in the shop after an accident.



Does Shelter Mutual Insurance Offer Driver Discounts?

Like with most other auto insurance providers, Shelter Insurance offers multiple discounts for auto insurance such as:

  • Good student discounts
  • Military discounts
  • Safe driver discounts
  • Multiple car discounts
  • Pay-in-full discounts
  • Accident prevention course discounts
  • Driver’s education course discounts
  • Airbag and seat belt discounts

You may also be able to save some money on your Shelter Insurance car policy if you have additional types of policies with the company, as well.



How Does Shelter Mutual Insurance's Process Work?

You can get an online quote for a Shelter Mutual Insurance auto policy by visiting the company’s website and submitting the required information about yourself, your vehicle, and your driving habits. 

Existing Shelter Mutual Insurance customers can use their Shelter Insurance accounts to access their policies and other information on the website. If you have a Shelter Insurance account, you can also pay your bills online using a credit card, debit card, or checking account. 

Shelter Insurance also has a mobile app that allows you to pay bills, access your insurance ID card, file claims, view your policy details, or find an agent. 

To file a claim with Shelter Mutual Insurance, go to the company website or call. If you want to cancel a Shelter Insurance policy, we recommend calling the company or talking to your agent.



Shelter Mutual Insurance Reviews

Shelter Mutual Insurance has an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau, though it’s not accredited with the organization. Companies are not obligated to get BBB accreditation, but it shows potential customers that the company is willing to make good faith efforts to resolve any concerns.

Our research revealed that 39 customer complaints were filed with the BBB against Shelter Insurance in the last three years over issues like billing or problems with service. The company has responded to each complaint and closed 20 of them in the last 12 months. In cases where the problem was caused by a company or agency error, the company has been willing to admit its mistake and take quick action to find a solution.



Our Verdict: Shelter Mutual Insurance 

Overall, we think that Shelter Mutual Insurance is a good provider for an auto insurance policy if you live in central or southern U.S. In fact, it was ranked the best auto insurance provider in the central region in the J.D. Power 2019 Auto Insurance Study, which looked into many factors like customer interaction and billing process. However, since its areas of services are limited to midwestern and southern regions, you will have to look elsewhere if you live in a state not serviced by Shelter Insurance.




Our Recommendations For Auto Insurance

If you would like to look at other insurance providers before making your decision, you can choose from our list of 12 best auto insurance providers. To make sure you get the best value for your money, we recommend getting at least three quotes when shopping for something as important as a car insurance policy. 

However, do not just go by the price. At the end of the day, a company’s track record, financial stability, and customer satisfaction ratings are as important as the quotes when it comes to choosing the right provider. 

Companies like Geico car insurance, USAA car insurance, and Progressive car insurance, which topped our rankings, are known for their extensive coverage options and customer service, and would be great starting points. Geico has high ratings from Standard & Poor (S&P) and AM Best for financial strength, while USAA offers exceptional coverage for military members and their families. 

Get A Quote

Whenever you shop for car insurance, we recommend getting quotes from multiple providers so you can compare coverage and rates. In addition to the insurance company you choose, factors such as your age, vehicle make and model, and driving history can affect your premium, so what’s best for your neighbor might not be best for you.

Use our tool below or call Motor1's designated quotes team at (855) 518-0148 to start comparing personalized car insurance quotes for providers available in your state:


Read our other insurance articles:

Gallery: Three Ships Images