While vehicles come pre-equipped with car floor mats, they may not be the best option for keeping your vehicle’s floor clean. The original equipment manufacturer (OEM) includes floor mats for your new car that may be more for decoration than for weather protection.

In this article, we recommend the best car floor mats based on our testing and review of heavy-duty rubber floor mats and custom-fit floor liners designed for specific vehicles. We also tested universal floor mats, or universal-fit mats, in our search to find high-quality floor mats that are the perfect fit for your vehicle.

#1 Best Overall: Smartliner Custom Fit Floor Mats

Smartliner Custom Fit Floor Mats

Check Price

The Smartliner Custom Fit Floor Mats are our top choice due to their fit inside our test vehicle, water retention, and lack of movement. This car floor mat fit effortlessly into place and covered the entirety of the vehicle’s floor.

Despite being one of the two car floor mats we tested that didn’t feature anti-slip nibs, the Smartliner Custom Fit Floor Mats had absolutely no movement whatsoever when in use. Regardless of our tester’s feet positioning or whether they dragged their feet, this car floor mat wouldn’t move an inch.

Key Features

  • Molded design to fit the vehicle
  • High edge rims
  • Custom-fit to the specific test vehicle make and model

Our Experience

Smartliner Custom Fit Floor Mats

The Smartliner Custom Fit Floor Mats are easy to install and had a great fit in our test vehicle. The high-edge rims retain any water dragged into the car, and the molded custom-fit design collects any dust or debris from the bottom of your shoes. The only drawback to this product is that it’s notably more expensive than the other car floor mats that we tested.

Overall Rating5 out of 5
Sizing5
Durability5
Movement5
Water Retention5
Odor5
  • Sizing: Custom-fit and perfectly molded for the interior of our test vehicle, the Smartliner floor mats could not have been sized any better. Every square inch of the car’s carpet was covered, including the side walls of the vehicle.
  • Durability: While we didn’t test the Smartliner Custom Fit Floor Mats over an extended period of time, we did note the material it was made out of and its flexibility to determine the floor mats durability. The low-density polyethylene material makes for a long-lasting and durable floor mat.
  • Movement: With its molded design, the Smartliner Custom Fit Floor Mats did not move at all throughout the testing process.
  • Water Retention: The water retention of the Smartliner was head and shoulders above the rest of the car floor mats we tested.
  • Odor: While researching the best car floor mats, our team found that the overwhelming majority of these products had a strong rubber-like odor that could linger in your car’s interior for weeks. This was not the case with the Smartliner floor mats – there was absolutely no odor and no smell of rubber.

What Customers Are Saying

The Smartliner Custom Fit Floor Mats have an excellent Amazon customer review rating of 4.6 out of 5.0 stars. A total of 93 percent of reviewers rate this product 4.0 stars or higher.

“I have a sandy [driveway and] it is tracked into the floors of my cars. I got the full set, even the trunk. They fit like a glove and the price was a lot less than Weathertech. I will buy them again for future cars.”

– Rebecca M. via Amazon

#2 Best Design: Caterpillar CAT CAMT-9013

Caterpillar CAT CAMT-9013

Check Price

The design of the Caterpillar CAT CAMT-9013 car floor mat separates it from the competition. Although not custom fit to our test vehicle, the floor mats covered nearly all of the vehicle’s carpet. The CAT CAMT-9013 floor mats are perfect for a pickup truck or off-road vehicle, such as a Toyota Tacoma or an ATV, that sees tons of dirt, debris, and slush dragged into the vehicle’s interior.

Key Features

  • Trim-to-fit design
  • High retention walls
  • Rugged ridges

Our Experience

Caterpillar CAT CAMT-9013

Our team was impressed with the design of this three-piece set. Both the front mats and the backseat mats provided coverage over the test vehicle’s carpet floor mats. Additionally, the backseat car floor mats were the best-fitting and offered the most water retention compared to the other backseat car floor mats that we tested.

Overall Rating4 out of 5
Sizing4
Durability4
Movement4
Water Retention4
Odor4
  • Sizing: The trim-to-fit design of these floor mats meant that after a few adjustments, the mats were a near perfect fit in our test vehicle. These weather mats were one of our top picks in the automotive industry due to how well they fit and the high edge retention walls.
  • Durability: The specially designed weather rubber is stain-resistant and can handle just about any type of mess that you drag into your car.
  • Movement: Whether our product tester shuffled his feet or purposely attempted to dig his feet into the heel pad to move the floor mats, he could not manage to make these floor mats shift or move at all.
  • Water Retention: Due to its rugged ridges and high walls, the CAT CAMT-9013 car floor mats held water exceptionally well. Though not as good as the Smartliner car floor mats we tested, these mats were head and shoulders above others when it came to water retention.
  • Odor: Featuring high quality polymers, there was little to no smell from these non-toxic, BPA-free car floor mats. The product description explains that regardless of the heat and if all doors are closed, these mats have no odor and it is safe to sit in the vehicle. Through our testing, we found this to be true.

What Customers Are Saying

The Caterpillar CAT CAMT-9013 car floor mats receive positive reviews from customers, with a 4.4 out of 5.0 rating on Amazon. These car mats feature over 1,300 reviews, with 85 percent of reviewers rating the product 4.0 stars or higher.

“It’s nearly a perfect fit for a 2004 F-150 for the fronts with no trimming needed, full coverage with nice deep wells to hold the snow melt. Haven’t put the back strip in yet but don’t anticipate any issues. Looks great & they have no ‘funky odor’ [like] some new floor mats can have.”

– Buffalo Blue via Amazon

#3 WeatherTech Universal Trim To Fit

WeatherTech Universal Trim To Fit

Check Price

The WeatherTech Universal Trim To Fit Floor Mat was one of our review team’s favorite mats to use and test. These car floor mats prove that you don’t need a complicated design for a car floor mat.

The water retention of the car floor mats is impressive, especially taking into account the fact that there aren’t high retention walls on the mats. Although there are driver’s side and passenger side-specific mats, we weren’t blown away by the fit in the test vehicle.

Key Features

  • Trim-to-fit design
  • Patented MatGrip to prevent movement/slipping
  • Anti-skid ridges on the underside of the mat

Our Experience

WeatherTech Universal Trim To Fit

Our testing team was pleasantly surprised at the versatility of these car floor mats. Without being too bulky or needing high retention walls, these best-selling car floor mats do a great job of keeping dirt, debris, and messes within the confines of the floor mat itself.

Overall Rating3.8 out of 5
Sizing3
Durability4
Movement5
Water Retention3
Odor4
  • Sizing: The trim-to-fit design of the floor mats meant that after making some adjustments, these floor mats fit well in our test vehicle. Though we hoped for a more closely fitting floor mat due to the specific side of the car design of each front mat, these mats fit relatively well.
  • Durability: Built from thermoplastic elastomer (TPE), we didn’t need to test these mats over an extended period of time to know they’ll last. These mats are up to ISO 9001 and FMVSS302 standards, meaning you can trust that they will last for a long time.
  • Movement: With its patented MatGrip retention device, there was absolutely no movement from these car floor mats. Molded-in nibs attached to the bottom of the mats provide further peace of mind that they won’t move or slip under your pedals.
  • Water Retention: Our team was pleasantly surprised at the water retention of the WeatherTech car floor mats. However, other mats performed slightly better in this category.
  • Odor: These car floor mats are made out of a virtually odorless latex material. Through unboxing and testing we found this to be true. There was little to no odor of rubber.

What Customers Are Saying

The WeatherTech Universal Trim To Fit Floor Mats have over 2,300 Amazon reviews. A total of 90 percent of reviewers rate the product 4.0 stars or higher, and these car floor mats hold a rating of 4.6 stars overall.

“I am very happy with these mats. After reading so many reviews (most good, some bad) I decided to take a chance and just order them. I’m glad I did. They do not look cheap, they fit the area, they’re heavy and rugged, and I didn’t pay $130 …”

– Someone Female via Amazon

#4 OxGord Car Floor Mats

OxGord Car Floor Mats

Check Price

The OxGord Car Floor Mat is a great option if you’re looking for a car floor mat that won’t break the bank. These were the cheapest car floor mats that we tested, though the price doesn’t reflect the quality of the mats. The product is simple, yet effective.

The OxGord mats come in several color options, including ridge-black, beige, and gray.

Key Features

  • Waterproof and stain-resistant
  • Rubberized nibs on bottom of mat to prevent movement
  • Made from advanced formula rubber

Our Experience

OxGord Car Floor Mats

Our product testing team was surprised at the durability of the OxGord car floor mats, though we were hoping for a better fit inside our test vehicle. Though the mats don’t feature high retention walls or anti-slip technology, they work well at keeping your car’s carpet clean and stay in place.

Overall Rating3.6 out of 5
Sizing3
Durability4
Movement4
Water Retention3
Odor4
  • Sizing: Featuring a trim-to-fit design, these car floor mats weren’t as wide as we were hoping. Though trimming down the mats with a pair of kitchen scissors made them fit our test vehicle better, especially on the driver’s side, they left a little too much of the car’s carpet uncovered for our liking.
  • Durability: Made from an advanced formula rubber, these mats should last a long time. The high-quality rubber mats are relatively lightweight, but our team believes they’ll stand the test of time.
  • Movement: Although the bottom of the floor mats features relatively understated anti-slip technology, our team could barely get the mats to shift under our feet. The OxGord car floor mats prove that you don’t need fancy designs to keep your floor mats in one place.
  • Water Retention: Though these car floor mats will be easy to clean, they won’t be great at keeping slush, snow, or water off of your vehicle’s carpet. The low height of the exterior retention walls mean dirt and water can slosh out of the mat itself and onto the car’s carpet.
  • Odor: The product description details state that you will likely need to air these mats out before installing. This is due to the fact that the OxGord Car Floor Mats come fresh from the factory, and smell like it. The reason this floor mat didn’t score lower on our odor criteria was because of the notice in the product description.

What Customers Are Saying

With more than 5,600 Amazon reviews, the OxGord Car Floor Mats have an overall rating of 4.3 out of 5.0 stars. These car floor mats receive generally positive reviews, with 81 percent of reviewers rating the product over 4.0 stars.

“I bought these mats for my 2011 Ford Edge. They fit great right outta the box. I love them. I took the advice of other reviews and aired them out for a couple days. That eliminates the chemical smell. Definitely worth the price!”

– Mr. Marty via Amazon

#5 Armor All 78840ZN All Season Floor Mat

Armor All 78840ZN All Season Floor Mat

Check Price

The Armor All 78840ZN All Season Floor Mat is the only sub-zero weather-specific floor mat that we tested. These car floor mats are designed to withstand temperatures below zero degrees Fahrenheit without the mats curling, cracking, or hardening.

The car floor mats feature patent-pending anti-slip technology in the form of the Carpet Claw, which secures the mats in place and prevents them from moving. Additionally, the floor mats are manufactured from an industry leader in car care for the past 50 years.

Key Features

  • Designed to withstand sub-zero weather conditions
  • Patent-pending Carpet Claw to prevent movement

Our Experience

Armor All 78840ZN All Season Floor Mat

Through rigorous testing, we found the Armor All 78840ZN All Season Floor Mat to be a great option for floor protection.

Overall Rating3.4 out of 5
Sizing3
Durability4
Movement3
Water Retention4
Odor3
  • Sizing: The trim-to-fit design of these floor mats meant that there were adjustments needed for the mats to fit. After cutting and trimming, the mats worked well in our test vehicle.
  • Durability: Made from heavy-duty rubber, these car floor mats are built to withstand sub-zero temperatures without losing their original form. They are built to last.
  • Movement: There was little to no movement of these car floor mats when kicked or when feet were shuffled.
  • Water Retention: Though the retention walls were of average height, these car floor mats performed well in our water retention test. Our team credits the slats in the design of this car floor mat with retaining water.
  • Odor: Though other car floor mats came with notices in the product description about the potential odor of the mat, these did not. Upon unboxing this product, our testing team was met with a strong odor of burnt rubber and chemicals. However, following testing, these car floor mats no longer smelled at all. We recommend letting the mats air out before installing them in your vehicle.

What Customers Are Saying

With about 20,000 Amazon reviews, the Armor All 78840ZN All Season Floor Mat has an overall rating of 4.5 out of 5.0 stars. The vast majority of reviews are positive, with 89 percent of reviewers rating this product 4.0 stars or higher.

“I traded from fabric [floor mats] to these ones and will never go back. These mats are made for mud, dirt, spills, and so much more! They say you have to cut them to fit but I drive a 2015 Nissian Altima and all four fit perfectly! I did like that since they are very heavy-duty …”

– Ruben0329 via Amazon

Car Floor Mats Buyers Guide

The best car floor mat depends on your needs. Are you looking for a floor mat to decorate the interior of your vehicle? Do you want a mat that’s going to protect your car’s carpet and is easy to clean? Consider the following before making your purchase.

  • Sizing: Sizing is arguably the most important factor to consider when shopping for a car floor mat. Regardless of if you’re looking at standard universal fit or custom fit floor mats, a car floor mat should cover as much of the car’s carpet area as possible while not impeding the pedals in your vehicle.
  • Durability: Most car floor mats are built to last, however this is not always the case. Taking into account the durability of a car floor mat is a must for any drivers looking for a floor mat that is built to handle adverse weather conditions.
  • Movement: Movement is the biggest safety related factor in play for a car floor mat. A car floor mat that slides around under your feet and interferes with the pedals on the drivers side poses a risk to not only yourself, but other drivers on the road.
  • Water Retention: Water retention is a factor that should be seriously considered if you’re looking for a car floor mat to protect your vehicle’s carpet. The water retention of a car floor mat sheds light onto how much dirt/debris a floor mat can keep off the car’s carpet.
  • Odor: According to Amazon reviews, the vast majority of car floor mats have a burnt rubber smell that can leave your car smelling badly for weeks. Knowing whether or not a car floor mat’s smell is manageable is something you should consider.

Our Review Standards

The floor mats in this article went through two rounds of reviews. We started by searching Amazon for top products, looking at factors like Prime shipping eligibility, customer ratings, Amazon superlatives, and prices. The five floor mats that best met these standards were ordered by our team for testing.

Car Floor Mats Testing Process

To determine the best car floor mat, we thoroughly researched and rigorously tested each product with consideration for what most people would be looking for out of a car floor mat. We unboxed, trimmed down the mats (if necessary), fitted each mat in our test vehicle, and finally tested the water retention of each mat.

Below are a few more factors we considered when testing car floor mats.

Backseat Fit

Not every driver is worried about the coverage of the driver’s side floor mat, but rather the backseat. With kids and sporting equipment commonly thrown in the backseat, we tested not only the front mats, but also the backseat mats in determining our rating for our sizing criteria.

Pictured below are each company’s backseat mats so you can decide for yourself whether they will offer as much coverage as you need.

Smartliner Custom Fit Car Floor Mats

Smartliner Custom Fit Car Floor Mats

Caterpillar CAT CAMT-9013

Caterpillar CAT CAMT-9013

WeatherTech Universal Trim To Fit Floor Mats

WeatherTech Universal Trim To Fit Floor Mats

OxGord Car Floor Mats

OxGord Car Floor Mats

Armor All 78840ZN All Season Floor Mat

Armor All 78840ZN All Season Floor Mat

Adverse Weather

Some drivers choose a car floor mat based on visual appeal, but most are looking for a mat that can handle inclement weather.

We bent, folded, and manipulated each mat to test its durability. We also tested each mat for its water retention abilities by seeing how much water each mat could hold without the water spilling off the mat. Our water retention test is meant to mimic dirt, grime, and slush that’s dragged into the vehicle cabin and test how well each mat handles adverse conditions.

Price

Prior to testing and review, we researched the leading brands of car floor mats. The mats we selected had prices ranging from around $20 to $140.

Frequently Asked Questions

*Data accurate at time of publication.