Fair Market Range: $8,756 - $10,513

The Toyota Avalon is more of a near-luxury sedan, but it still offers owners lots of room and a comfortable ride. If you don't mind the lack of prestige from the vehicle, then this is a big four-door to take a serious look at. While KBB shows the 2011 model as the first year with prices below $10,000, there are lots of listings online for newer examples within this price point.