Average Cost: $18,963

Toyota’s pickup truck reputation is built on reliability and ruggedness. The 2012 Tacoma delivers on both, with the choice of two dependable engines – a 2.7-liter four-cylinder or a 4.0-liter V6 – as well as manual or automatic transmissions and two- or four-wheel drive. That reputation leads to very high resale values, with an average used price of $18,963. The good news is that even high-mileage Tacomas can still be reliable trucks.