Average Cost: $19,064

Like the Tacoma, the Toyota Tundra is also known for being a tough, dependable pickup. The 2011 Tundra came standard with a 4.0-liter V6, but 4.6-liter and 5.7-liter V8s were optional. The Tundra offers a surprisingly smooth ride for such a large pickup, as well as a very spacious interior. Towing and hauling capacity are midpack among other large pickups, making the Tundra a good all-arounder. Average used prices sit at $19,064.